Misconceptions: Antivirus Software

By Chris Williams

The antivirus dichotomy

Is antivirus (AV) software a necessity, or does it simply offer users a false sense of security? In reality, this is a false dichotomy as both perspectives on this topic are somewhat true. While AV software protects inexperienced users from a variety of common threats, it doesn’t protect high-profile users (managers, executives, etc.) from advanced threats; in the latter case, training these users to avoid high-risk behavior is vital. Safe Internet browsing practices, awareness of common social engineering tactics, and use of physical access controls within the environment are all important to reduce malware exposure. If systems never come in direct contact with malicious code, then the chances of infection drop accordingly.

Does this mean that end users with little to no security training should go without antimalware protection of any sort? Absolutely not. However, it is critical to understand that in IT security, defensive technology is perpetually catching up to offense. If you’re a high-profile enough target for a malicious attacker to expend one of their most valuable commodities (E.G. a zero day exploit) to crack, then just know that by definition your AV software is not going to prevent the resulting damage—if it detects the attack at all. In other words, additional defense mechanisms are required to compensate for the limitations posed by antivirus programs.


Defense-in-depth is the methodology which IT security practitioners rely upon to secure complex systems from a wide variety of threats; the basic premise is to employ multiple overlapping security measures to protect each asset.

The term “layering” is often used to describe defense-in-depth. For each access point that exists within a system, there must exist at least one defense mechanism, or layer. Each successive layer adds to the security of the system, since an attack which breaches the first layer should hypothetically fail to breach the second layer. (Otherwise, why is the second layer even there?) If multiple security measures are vulnerable to the same exploit, it defeats the purpose; that would be like having an outside security door, an inside security door, and the door to the most securely guarded portion of the building all keyed to the same key. If a malicious person obtains that key, then all of the security mechanisms are defeated simultaneously.

What does this have to do with antivirus software? Simply this: AV programs have known shortcomings that can, and must, be anticipated in order to maintain a secure environment. And while the protection offered by these software platforms does almost unarguably outweigh the negatives, there is no antivirus on the market which can be considered “perfect”. Lastly, even if a perfect AV package were developed (hypothetically), malware is only one threat vector; there are dozens of other means that malicious attackers use which would be virtually unhindered.

The takeaway

Even with all of the above caveats in mind, it is essential in today’s reality to run antivirus software on endpoints such as user workstations and public-facing servers. The following points may provide some additional guidance:

  • Administrators and security professionals should research and learn about all of the AV software on the market and select one which suits their needs. The most popular platforms aren’t necessarily the best, nor are the most expensive options inherently better than others.
  • A second-opinion software option should be kept on stand-by just in case; due to differences in definitions and analysis methods, it is often necessary to scan using multiple different vendors.
  • Become familiar with services such as VirusTotal (virustotal.com) which can, for no charge, examine suspicious files and URLs in a sandbox environment.
  • Not all malware are viruses, and it is often necessary to use specialized tools to detect or remove threats such as spyware/adware.
  • One cannot stress this enough: AV software is simply one piece of the larger puzzle, rather than a one-and-done solution to all network security ailments.

Copyright © 2017 ParadoxPrime IA, All rights reserved

Recognizing Computer Threats – Data Breach Awareness, Part I

By Chris Williams

Data breach

If it seems like data breaches are becoming more and more commonplace all the time, that’s because it’s true: the frequency of data breach and security incidents that result in some level of data leakage is on the rise. On top of that, the public’s perception of these incidents is becoming more acute. This is in part because a larger percentage of data breaches are being publicized than ever before. Due to the prevalence of both national and state laws which require companies to notify consumers when their personally identifiable information (PII) is compromised, it is essentially unavoidable: organizations must have procedures in their incident response plans to deal with these types of contingencies. Private organizations such as Payment Card Institute (PCI) have their own rules concerning how breach notifications must take place; they typically enforce such policies through audits and by assessing non-compliance penalties.

Breach notifications

Best practice after a data breach is to send breach notification notices out as soon as the scope of the incident has been reasonably well determined; this is both for compliance purposes as well as for good “public relations”. On the other hand, companies that are slow to publicize data breaches are often maligned in the court of public opinion. Despite the bad PR that can occur when a company’s security practices are implicated after a security incident, some public forgiveness can be gained by simply being forthcoming. Additionally, when organizations provide supplemental services such as credit monitoring to data breach victims, the extra expense is typically justified by the positive effect on consumer confidence. Transparency, expediency, and ownership of the incident are surprisingly effective tools in retaining customers after an incident occurs.

All this being said, with the sheer number of incidents happening, consumers still need to understand how to minimize their risks. It is important to know what steps to take if an incident occurs targeting a service provider or retailer that they utilize. It is also vital to recognize that not all organizations are forthcoming when a breach occurs, even if the law says they should be.

Webmail accounts: use unique passwords

A data breach that compromises your email account password can mean more than just a loss of privacy (although that is of course the primary concern since most of us are uncomfortable with the prospect of strangers reading our emails). Exposure of personally identifiable information (PII) is often linked to identity theft and other forms of fraud; criminals may use this info directly or sell it via black market. This information is used to open fraudulent bank accounts, make purchases with compromised payment cards, and so on. Many users fail to consider the considerable level of PII that is exposed during a data breach. The following non-comprehensive list includes a few good examples:

Correspondences with companies you do business with, including healthcare providers (noteworthy because of the depth of information these companies retain); lists of personal friends, family members, and associates; employment-related messages such as recruitment or application emails; vacation plans; event invites; receipts for purchases, often with partially visible payment information; billing and shipping addresses; and much, much more.

A compromised webmail account can provide hackers with tremendous detail regarding your personal life—and accounts you may have with e-commerce sites and other services—therefore it is important not to re-use any passwords across multiple different services.

Scenario: compromised webmail password

Tom uses Yahoo for webmail. Tom’s yahoo.com email address is also the user name for his Amazon account, and the passwords for his Yahoo and Amazon profiles are identical. Let’s imagine his Yahoo password is stolen during a mass data breach; hackers can then gain access to his inbox, and read all of his messages. From there they determine that he has an Amazon account by skimming through transaction emails. Their next step will of course be Amazon.com. By simply entering the same password used to access his Yahoo inbox they will easily gain access to Tom’s Amazon account, because the password was re-used for both accounts; by contrast, they could not have done so if the passwords were different. (They would, however, still have his Amazon user name since it’s the same as his Yahoo email address).

Amazon, like most e-commerce retailers, allows customers to re-use payment cards that they have previously saved.  Whoever has access to Tom’s account also has access to make unauthorized purchases—without even having to provide a credit card.

The takeaway

Breach notification laws exist to protect consumers whose protected information may have been affected by a security breach. Unfortunately, these laws are not as comprehensive or as compelling as they could be, and so many companies are still slow to report & publicize incidents.

Using the same credentials for multiple email and/or other accounts is inadvisable. This practice creates a single point of failure by which attackers can gain access to all of your private data. Monitor your inbox for unsolicited messages, and check your Sent folder from time to time. Again, just because your webmail provider has not announced an incident does not mean no such event has taken place.

There’s plenty more so say about this topic: we’ll be back soon with part II!

Copyright © 2016 ParadoxPrime IA, All rights reserved

Recognizing Computer Threats – Malware

By Chris Williams

Why is my PC running so slowly?

Could it be malware? Some non-malicious events can certainly make your Windows computer run slowly. Such causes range from operating system updates downloading from Microsoft at inopportune times, unnecessary processes/services running in the background, disk fragmentation, or it could just be overdue for a restart (this fixes more ailments than you might think!).

However, if you’re fairly certain it isn’t any of these issues, or if you’re just more paranoid than most, the next several paragraphs detail some things to look at which you can easily access via the Resource Monitor. Keep in mind, that the more you understand about the computer’s performance under normal conditions, the more likely you’ll be able to spot malicious activity taking place. For example, many Windows users have a fairly good idea of how much storage space is left on their computers; this is certainly useful information to have for normal day-to-day operations of the machine. Same holds true when it comes to monitoring how much memory, CPU time, or bandwidth is being utilized.

Consistently High CPU Usage

Malware tends to consume a significant amount of CPU time, so if your CPU Usage meter is consistently pegged at close to 100% it could be an indication of malware infection. Looking at the CPU Usage History can help differentiate if it’s just a short-term spike as opposed to something that’s been going for a longer time frame. We recommend scanning for malware, in particular if your CPU time doesn’t fall to a normal level after a period of relative inactivity.

Memory (RAM) Allocation

Malicious software can run processes in the background that require noticeable amounts of memory, as well as spawning related services that you may not recognize. One approach is to (with as few open applications as possible) make note of any processes or services you are suspicious of, and simply Google them. You will likely find a lot of info regarding Windows system processes as well as services that are related to legitimate applications; in the event that you discover a process that appears to be malicious, it’s important to conduct a thorough malware scan immediately.

Missing Disk Space

Viruses are self-replicating and can, if left unchecked, take up a sizable portion of disk space within a short period of time. This adversely affects the computer’s performance because, as the disk’s capacity approaches its limit, the read/write speed of that drive effectively diminishes. If one day your drive has 200 GB space remaining and the next day that same drive is inexplicably down to 20 GB, the next logical step would be to scan for malware.

Network Utilization

Some malware types—in particular, spyware—can be used to obtain information about you or your computer and then forward it back “home” to a hacker or other malicious user. Whether this information is used for identity theft, or is simply reconnaissance for a future attack, there is still some amount of network activity required for that data to reach its destination. It can be difficult to detect in a home environment but it is still important to know the signs; these include unfamiliar networking services or connections to unknown hosts, and an unusually high level of network activity (in particular when you’re not browsing the internet and have few or no networked devices talking back and forth).

Browser Redirection

After installing a “free” program or file of dubious origin, you may find that your web browser’s home page has been changed, or perhaps there are unusual toolbars you didn’t previously have installed; both cases are cause for concern and should be investigated. Spyware and adware often contain browser hijacking components, create pop-up ads, and cause other inconveniences when surfing the Web. While it is common for legitimate sites to try to bundle you with unwanted programs, there will (should) always be an opt-out, simply requiring you de-select extra software prior to confirming the download and/or installation. Less reputable sites may not give you this option—this is of course a red flag, but it comes too late as you’ll have already exposed your system to the threat.

Crashing or Locking Up

When a PC frequently crashes or freezes, it could mean a few things, imminent hardware failure being among them. While a corrupted hard disk or a bad memory module is definitely urgent, the threat of malware requires greater immediacy in order to ensure your personal privacy and critical data are protected; therefore it is recommended to scan the system for intrusion upon recovery from a crash. (Provided that the system is stable enough to do so.)

Addressing the threat of Malware

To supplement whatever your preferred antivirus/anti-malware is capable of detecting (which isn’t everything), it is recommended to run more than one antivirus application on a regular basis; by conducting in-depth scans using multiple different detection engines you can have some certainty that your computer is safe. Additionally, some varieties of malware (spyware, frequently) simply necessitate having specialized tools available to combat them. Lastly, since many advanced malware programs can obfuscate themselves, detection methods also need to take that into consideration; one such example is Avast’s “boot-time scan” feature, which scans the computer prior to booting up the operating system—thus negating the malware’s ability to hide itself within the file system.
A long list of recommendations is sure to follow in a future post. But for now, here are some answers to the specific threats mentioned in this article:
Avast (antivirus)
Malwarebytes (antivirus)
Webroot (antivirus)
Hitman Pro (“second opinion” antivirus)
Spybot Search and Destroy (anti-spyware)
TDSSKiller (rootkit remover)

Understanding and avoiding future threats

Detection, prevention, and remediation are critical to keeping your computer safe from malware; but, an even better approach is to avoid infection in the first place. Certain “high risk” activities amplify your chances for exposure almost exponentially. This includes P2P sharing, visiting adult websites, and downloading software through unscrupulous repositories. Less reputable repository sites tack on additional programs, usually spyware or adware, without your explicit permission. (You can get frequently around this by paying attention during the installation process, and deselecting any add-ons).

Phishing and questionable links/files

Another major threat comes via email. While phishing emails certainly aren’t new, the sheer volume and complexity of these messages is increasing dramatically. The average user will most likely be fooled at some point and click on something they shouldn’t have. This frequently comes in the form of a malicious link that delivers its payload via cross-site scripting. Another method which is less common nowadays due to spam filtering techniques is to send a specially crafted file which spoofs a .pdf, .zip, or other type of benign file extension, but actually contains a malware package which installs itself once executed by the user. Whatever the mechanism, the goal is to compromise the victim’s system by infecting it with malware.

One last thing to be very conscious of is that attackers can spoof addresses from your contact list in order to make the phishing message seem more trustworthy; for all of these reasons, here are some good practices to follow:
• Assume that all unsolicited file attachments are phishing attempts and delete them, regardless of type.
• Verify the legitimacy of suspicious links you receive from known contacts before clicking on them. Same holds true with URLs sent to you via messaging apps and SMS/MMS.
• If the subject line doesn’t match the body, or if there is no message body, consider it suspicious.
• Check the email header information to verify that the “from” address matches the actual sender’s email address. This can be difficult with advertisement emails as they often use aliases.
• When in doubt, delete the message.
• Use free services such as Virustotal.com to analyze even “safe” URLs, for additional reassurance.

The Takeaway

PCs tend to slow down and generally perform less optimally over time. However, excessive slowness can be a sign of malware or other malicious activity affecting your system. Any single anti-malware solution is insufficient to address all of the various threats on the landscape; instead of relying on just one favorite become accustomed to using multiple virus detection engines to minimize risks. Safe browsing practices and an understanding of phishing campaigns are two of the keys to staying relatively safe online.


Copyright © 2016 ParadoxPrime IA, All rights reserved